Strategic everything equals strategic nothing

Business is now awash with strategy and almost none of it has anything thing to do with strategy.  The word strategy or strategic is just put at the front of existing terms to make them sound mystic and important and it is all basically bollocks.  Goodness knows it is rare enough to find actual strategy rather than check box exercises or the annual rewrite of the mission, vision and values (and I'll return to organisational values in another blog soon as that is an interesting aside).

This morning on the business news site I subscribe to I saw the following headline -
APN New & Media, publisher of the New Zealand Herald, has appointed Deutsche Bank to undertake a strategic review of its media assets.
If we take the word strategic out we have -
APN New & Media, publisher of the New Zealand Herald, has appointed Deutsche Bank to undertake a review of its media asset
And so the question is of course what is the point of the word strategic except to make it sound important and justify the appointment of very expensive consultants.

Unfortunately if this was an isolated example it would be interesting but when I saw this it was the straw that broke my blogging back and I just had to write about it as the business community is now inundated with strategic everything.  I went to Google news and typed strategic business and this is what the headlines (all from the last 9 hours) say:

  • Harnessing Strategic Business Growth
  • APN undertakes strategic review of its NZ assets
  • While we have already taken significant strategic steps to transition our business to the new digital media landscape, we are excited about the financial ...
  • The first in the industry to link both business strategy and portfolio strategy with transaction management and execution, PortfolioCommand(SM) combines ...
  • Supertankers Delayed in China as Nation Fills Strategic Reserves
  • Bar Harbor Bankshares Announces Strategic Acquisition of Border ...
  • The company selected GlobalEnglish after an exhaustive search for a strategic communications partner capable of providing a global, scalable solution that ...
Admittedly a couple of those stories are strategic but the rest use the term for aggrandisement and the bottom line is the word is now generically used instead of the word 'important' when it needs to be used at all.  

I plan to double my charge out rate as a consultant in the future as I no longer plan to read anything, I will be strategically reviewing documents.......

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mintzberg and Waters' strategy model

Image
It is interesting how some strategic management models come and go whilst other ones seem to survive the test of time.  In 1985 Henry Mintzberg (one of the leading strategic management thinkers) and James Waters developed a model to demonstrate how the strategy that is ultimately delivered is made of two parts; deliberate strategy (what the organisation set out to do) and emergent strategy (what happened on the way). In their original paper the model looks just a little clunky, word processing not as it is today, but very recognisable for all scholars and practitioners. And although the concept of the model hasn't changed at all, it does look a little funkier with a 'lick of paint'. The model still communicates with a simplicity that belies the revolutionary nature of what it was at the time.  It looks obvious with hindsight that of course we haven't got a crystal ball and the world changes so where we end up is a combination of where we were heade
Read more

Double Hermeneutic

I came across this term (pronounced 'her men you tic') in my strategic management PhD travels and was quite intrigued by it as it's both simple (despite its name) and very enlightening.  Hopefully I'll do the simple part justice here!!!! It was coined by  Anthony Giddens , a famous British sociologist, and it reveals a major difference in the way we should (stress on the should) theorise about the natural world versus our social world and of particular interest to me, theories about how we should manage people. In essence, a theory about our natural world has no impact on the natural world which remains the same no matter what we think.  For example it was previously thought that the world was flat (and yes there are some of you still out there) but that didn't change the shape of the earth which remained a sphere (oh yes it is).  This is a single hermeneutic. However in the social sciences this isn't the case and, if for example, a management theory gains su
Read more

If planning is everything, Maybe its nothing.

A blog back on my subject area, strategic planning or strategic management to use the correct term for the academic field. I have been reading an interesting article entitled 'If planning is everything, Maybe its nothing' written back in 1973 by Aaron Wildavsky.  It is almost a fore runner to one of the largest debates in strategic management, whether strategy should be planned and deliberate or it emerges naturally as part of general management activities. The article makes some very interesting points but it does read a little gloomily as though Mr Wildavsky hasn't got a lot of time for planners in general.  His particular interest is planning in the 3rd world (although it wasn't called the 3rd world then) and he observes that in amongst all the money poured into formal plans and planning, the results have been pretty disappointing. It raises another interesting argument/point and that is the difference between the plan and the outcomes.  He appears to be arguing t
Read more